Which Makes The Most Sense: Dump Trailers vs. Roll-off Dumpster

For any home project, removing the waste produced can quickly become a significant expense, so it’s essential to carefully consider all of your options to find the most cost-effective solution. The two most common options you’ll come across are dump trailers and roll-off dumpsters. Choosing the right one for your project can be a difficult decision to make, so we’ve put together some of the differences between them.

What is a Dump Trailer?

Dump trailers are purpose-built containers equipped with wheels, tall sidewalls, and a hinged lid, designed specifically for transporting waste materials to disposal sites. They come in a range of sizes and with different types of frames, each with its own characteristics and benefits. Typically, the channel frame will be the least expensive option, but it will have a weaker frame and a smaller dump capacity. The I-beam option is mid-sized with a more robust frame than the channel frame, but it can carry less than the tubular frame. And the tubular frame is the strongest and most expensive option.

Keep your vehicle’s towing capabilities in mind when you are choosing a dump trailer. Some trailers are light enough that they can be towed behind a rugged four-wheeler, while others will require a gross vehicle weight of 20,000 pounds and need dual axles. Be sure to check your vehicle’s specifications before renting or purchasing a dump trailer.

What is a Roll-off Dumpster?

On the other hand, a roll-off dumpster is transported by a specialized truck and is a type of open-topped waste container. These dumpsters are typically rented and are well-suited for residential projects. And even better, the company delivering the dumpster will handle all of the dumping needs for you.

Even though roll-off dumpsters are able to hold more than dump trailers, there are restrictions to consider. Certain materials, including tires, paints, motor oils, asbestos, batteries, and fuels, will be prohibited from being placed in roll-off dumpsters as these materials may pose a risk to animals or people if they are not disposed of properly.

At redbox+ Dumpsters of Toledo, we can help you set up a rental that can typically be delivered to your property the next day. Our team can even assist you in determining the appropriate size dumpster your project will require, which can save you time and money! We offer a range of services for projects such as roofing, room cleanouts, and landscaping renovations.

How Much Can Each Hold?

Both dump trailers and roll-off dumpsters are available in a range of sizes. Dumpster trailers will usually range from 8 to 20 feet in length, with 12 to 14 feet being the most common. Large dump trucks can typically carry about 14 tons, while smaller ones can handle 6.5 to 7.5 tons.

Roll-off dumpsters come in a variety of sizes as well, including:

– 10-yard roll-off dumpster: This size can hold up to 10 cubic yards of material, which is equivalent to about three pick-up trucks of debris or 50 to 70 33-gallon trash bags.
– 20-yard roll-off dumpster: These can hold up to 20 cubic yards of waste (equivalent to six pick-up truck beds of debris or 110 to 130 33-gallon trash bags).
– 30-yard roll-off dumpster: These are able to hold 30 cubic yards of material (approximately the same as nine pick-up truck beds or 170 to 190 33-gallon trash bags).
– 40-yard roll-off dumpster: This size can hold up to 40 cubic yards of waste, which is the same as filling up the bed of 12 pick-up trucks (or 230 to 250 33-gallon trash bags).

How Much Do They Cost?

Like many DIY solutions, dump trailers tend to cost less than renting a dumpster. However, there are several additional costs to consider when renting either a dump trailer or a roll-off dumpster. If you are renting a dump trailer, you will need a vehicle capable of towing it, which may incur an additional cost. You might also need to purchase a trailer hitch to attach the trailer to your vehicle. Additionally, there will be the cost of the gas it takes to transport the trailer to and from the dump, the project site, and the rental location.

With a roll-off dumpster, you may incur overage fees if you exceed the capacity of the dumpster in terms of volume or weight. You might also need to pay for any additional trips to the dump if you require the rental company to make multiple trips during your rental period. Both types of dumpsters will typically require dump fees at the landfill, regardless of who is transporting the waste.

Other Factors to Consider

The price is not the only factor you should consider when choosing between a dump trailer and a roll-off dumpster. A big one is convenience. Usually, projects that require waste removal are big projects. Do you really want to add to your work by hauling a junk trailer to the dump? A roll-off dumpster company will take care of that for you. You might be at the mercy of their schedule, but at redbox+ Dumpsters of Toledo, we can handle most service requests within 24 hours.

Roll-off dumpsters will often require more room, which means that you can fit more waste into the dumpster. This does mean that you will need to have more space available to park the dumpster.

Rent Today with redbox+ Dumpsters of Toledo

Find the convenience and ease of working with redbox+ Dumpsters of Toledo for your next dumpster rental needs. We can usually deliver a roll-off dumpster within 24 hours of you making the reservation. redbox+ Dumpsters of Toledo is a waste management partner you can count on for the entirety of your project. Call us when you need the bin emptied, and we’ll do the dumping for you. We can return or replace your roll-off dumpster within the same day to help you avoid any slowdowns with your project. Call us to schedule the pick-up time when you finish the job. Contact us today to get dumping tomorrow!