Dump Trailers vs. Roll-off Dumpster: Which Makes the Most Sense?

Disposing of waste during a home project can incur substantial costs, underscoring the importance of evaluating options for a cost-effective solution. The primary choices typically involve dump trailers and roll-off dumpster rentals, each with distinct characteristics. Let’s explore the differences between these two waste removal options.

What is a Dump Trailer?

Dump trailers are specialized containers equipped with wheels, high sides, and lids designed for transporting waste materials to a dump. They come in various sizes and feature different frame types, each offering unique characteristics and advantages. The channel frame, being the most economical choice, has a weaker frame and a smaller dump capacity. The I-beam, a mid-sized option, boasts a sturdier frame than the channel frame but has a lower carrying capacity than the tubular frame. The tubular frame stands out as the strongest and most expensive option.

When selecting a dump trailer, it’s crucial to consider your vehicle’s towing capabilities. Some trailers are lightweight enough to be towed by robust four-wheelers, while others may require a gross vehicle weight of 20,000 pounds and dual axles. Always check your vehicle’s specifications before renting or purchasing a dump trailer.

What is a Roll-off Dumpster?

A roll-off dumpster is a specialized open-topped waste container transported by a dedicated truck. Commonly rented, these dumpsters are well-suited for residential projects, with the company delivering the dumpster handling the disposal process for you.

While roll-off dumpsters offer a larger capacity compared to dump trailers, there are restrictions to consider. Certain materials, such as tires, paints, motor oils, asbestos, batteries, and fuels, are prohibited from being placed in roll-off dumpsters due to potential risks to animals or people if improperly disposed of.

At redbox+ Dumpsters of West Los Angeles, we can assist you in setting up a rental that is typically delivered to your property the next day. Our team can help determine the appropriate size for your project, saving you time and money. We provide a variety of services for projects like roofing, room cleanouts, and landscaping renovations.

 

How Much Can Each Hold?

Dumpster trailers and roll-off dumpsters come in various sizes. Dumpster trailers typically range from 8 to 20 feet in length, with 12 to 14 feet being the most common dimensions. Large dump trucks generally have a capacity of about 14 tons, while smaller ones can handle loads ranging from 6.5 to 7.5 tons.

 

Roll-off dumpsters also come in several sizes, including:

 

  • 10-yard roll-off dumpster: This size can hold up to 10 cubic yards of material, which is equivalent to about three pick-up trucks of debris or 50 to 70 33-gallon trash bags.
  • 20-yard roll-off dumpster: This size can hold up to 20 cubic yards of waste, which is equivalent to six pick-up truck beds of debris or 110 to 130 33-gallon trash bags.
  • 30-yard roll-off dumpster: This size can hold 30 cubic yards of material, which is approximately the same as nine pick-up truck beds of debris or 170 to 190 33-gallon trash bags.
  • 40-yard roll-off dumpster: This size can hold 40 cubic yards of material, which is about the same as filling up the bed of 12 pick-up trucks or 230 to 250 33-gallon trash bags.

 

How Much Do They Cost?

In general, dump trailers, akin to many do-it-yourself solutions, often have lower costs compared to renting a dumpster. However, when renting a dumpster trailer or a roll-off dumpster, there are additional expenses to consider. For dumpster trailers, you’ll need a vehicle capable of towing it, which could incur extra costs. Purchasing a trailer hitch to connect the dumpster trailer to your vehicle might also be necessary. Moreover, you’ll have to cover fuel expenses for transporting the dumpster trailer to and from the dump, the project site, and the rental location.

For a roll-off dumpster rental, overage fees may apply if you exceed the dumpster’s volume or weight capacity. Additional charges may be incurred for extra trips to the dump if you need the rental company to make multiple dumps during your rental period. Dump fees at the landfill are typically applicable for both types of dumpsters, irrespective of who transports the waste.

Other Factors to Consider

When deciding between a dump trailer and a roll-off dumpster, several factors should be taken into account, with convenience being a significant consideration. Typically, projects requiring waste removal are substantial endeavors. The question arises: do you really want the added responsibility of hauling a dump trailer to the dump? Opting for a roll-off dumpster company can alleviate this burden, as they manage the dumping process for you. While you may be subject to their schedule, at redbox+ Dumpsters, we can typically accommodate most service requests within 24 hours.

Roll-off dumpsters, however, often necessitate more space. While this allows for the accommodation of more waste in the dumpster—an advantage—it’s essential to have sufficient available space for parking the dumpster.

Rent Today with redbox+ Dumpsters of West Los Angeles

Discover convenience and simplicity with redbox+ Dumpsters when in need of rental dumpsters. We strive to deliver a roll-off dumpster rental within 24 hours of your reservation. As your trusted waste management partner throughout your project, you can rely on redbox+ Dumpsters. When it’s time for the bin to be emptied, just give us a call, and we’ll handle the dumping for you. We offer same-day return or replacement of your roll-off dumpster to ensure minimal disruption to your project. When your job is complete, contact us to schedule the pick-up time. Reach out today to initiate dumping tomorrow.

This website uses cookies

We inform you that this site uses own, technical and third parties cookies to make sure our web page is user-friendly and to guarantee a high functionality of the webpage. By continuing to browse this website, you declare to accept the use of cookies.